Wednesday, July 26, 2006

reminders on 17th July and 26th July 2006

---------- Forwarded message ----------From: Pankaj mody <modyps@gmail.com>Date: Jul 26, 2006 3:45 PMSubject: Fwd: Most Urgent - Reminder Two - APPLICATION MADE under RTI ACT on 10th July 2006 has to be furnished within 48 hours when there is issue of life and libertyTo: rdr-ahd@gujarat.gov.in , cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.inCc: CM Gujarat <cmgujarat@gujaratindia.com>, secinb@gujarat.gov.in, sectocm@gujarat.gov.in


From Pankaj S Mody
email modyps@gmail.com


The Public Information Officer,
Police Commissioner's Office
Shahibaug , Ahmedabad

Sir,


Kindly refer to the email on my reminder 1 seeking information on application under RTI Act on 10th July 2006.Till date I have not received any information inspite of the reminder. I am therefore sending present Second reminder to draw your attention. Kindly accord top priority and furnish the information called for forthwith.


Thanking You


Yours sincerely,


Pankaj S Mody
---------- Forwarded message ----------From: pankaj mody < modyps@gmail.com>Date: Jul 17, 2006 12:43 PM Subject: Most Urgent - Reminder 1- APPLICATION MADE under RTI ACT on 10th July 2006 has to be furnished within 48 hours when there is issue of life and libertyTo: rdr-ahd@gujarat.gov.in , cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.inCc: secinb@gujarat.gov.in, csguj@gujarat.gov.in, sectocm@gujarat.gov.in, gujarat state information commissioner <gscic@gujarat.gov.in >, rtigujaratpahel@yahoo.co.in,
.com
> \n\nFrom:-\nPankaj S Mody\nc/o Shri S S Modi\n2nd Floor,Janmangal Apt\n40 Brahman Mitra Mandal Society \nPaldi, Ahmedabad 380 006\n \n \n17th July 2006\n \n \n \n \nThe Police Commissioner and The Public Information Officer, \nShahibaug\nAhmedabad\n \n \nRespected Sir, \n \nSubject:-INFORMATION CALLED FOR UNDER RTI ACT ON July 10th 2006 has to be furnished with 48 hours when it is the issue of life. \n \nKindly refer to my above application and a copy annexed herewith for your ready reference . \nEven after lapse of 48 hours the inforamtion has not been provided to the undersigned \nYou are once again called upon to furnish the detailed infomation forthwith without any delay of time \n \n",1]
);
//-->
amritbrar2002@yahoo.co.in, creatorg@sify.com, fragrant_memories@yahoo.co.in, guru_ravindranath@yahoo.co.in , barkha@ndtv.com, Lok Satta Gujarat < loksattagujaratchapter@gmail.com>
From:-
Pankaj S Mody
c/o Shri S S Modi
2nd Floor,Janmangal Apt
40 Brahman Mitra Mandal Society
Paldi, Ahmedabad 380 006


17th July 2006




The Police Commissioner and The Public Information Officer,
Shahibaug
Ahmedabad


Respected Sir,

Subject:-INFORMATION CALLED FOR UNDER RTI ACT ON July 10th 2006 has to be furnished with 48 hours when it is the issue of life.

Kindly refer to my above application and a copy annexed herewith for your ready reference . Even after lapse of 48 hours the information has not been provided to the undersigned You are once again called upon to furnish the detailed infomation forthwith without any delay of time

I am being constrained to mark a copy to media as well to RTI activists as the matter concerning life and liberty is taken casually and lightly by the Police administration in Ahmedabad.so that the Police Commissioner's office sheds off complacent approach and starts treating the citizens with dignity and respect.

Kindly acknowledge receipt of present email as well as furnish detailed information called for.

Thanking you

Yours sincerely,

Pankaj Mody

Monday, July 10, 2006

calling for information under RTI on 10th July 2006 from Police Commissioner -ahmedabad

Gmail pankaj mody

CALLING FOR INFORMATION UNDER TO RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT WHEN THERE IS TOTAL DISREGARD OF THE INSTRUCTIONS OF THE CHIEF MINISTER OF GUJARAT

pankaj mody Mon, Jul 10, 2006 at 6:25 PM
To: rdr-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.in
Cc: rtigujaratpahel@yahoo.co.in, janpath1ad1@rediffmail.com, janpath1ad1@icenet.net, barkha@ndtv.com

Pankaj S Mody

C/o S S Modi.

2 nd Fl, Janmangal Apt

40 BMM Soc

Paldi ,

Ahmedabad 380 006

Email: modyps@gmail.com

10 th July 2006

The Police Commissioner

Shahibaug

Ahmedabad

Respected Sir

Subject:- Information called under Right to Information Act

I am enclosing copy of petition ( under Right to Information Act) dated 10th July 2006 ( affixing stamp of Rs 20/-) hand delivered to the Police Commissioner's office on 10th July 2006 delivered at 4.20 PM and registered by your registry vide 15219.

In view of threat to life as well as possible harassment and torture of the officers of police colluding with land mafia Mr. Nishit Pethalji Chavada (especially when Ghanshyam Chudasma , stenographer at Navrangpura Police station being arrested as reported today in news papers ) , I need to have the information within 48 hours of receipt of my communication to the Police Commissioner's office. The following link shows that Ghanshyam Chudasma was hand in glove with persons involved in the murder of Shri Pankaj Trivedi.

http://www.zeenews.com/znnew/articles.asp?aid=308097&sid=REG

http://cities.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=192053

I am also annexing the previous emails sent to the office of the Police Commissioner for ready reference and necessary action.

I am marking copy of the present email to Right to Information chapter in Ahmedabad as well as NDTV so as to draw their attention as to total disregard to the necessary instructions of the office of the Chief Minister of Gujarat and Mr. Chudasma , head of Vejalpur Police station working under Deputy Commissioner of Police Shri A K Jadeja is equally irresponsible and hand in glove with land mafia Nishit Pethalji Chavada and Mr. Jadeja (DCP) is too mild to control the staff working under him.

I humbly request you to furnish detailed information under Right to Information Act forthwith especially when it involves safety of the my life as well as safety of my family members. .

Thanking you.

Yours sincerely,

Pankaj S Mody

ENCLOSURE:- APPLICATION SUBMITTED UNDER RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT .

INFORMATION CALLED UNDER RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT (RTI)

From :-

PANKAJ S M0DY

C/O SHRI S S MODI

2ND FLOOR , JANMANGAL APT

NEAR KUTCHI SAMAJ HALL

40 BMM SOCIETY PALDI ,

AHMEDABAD 380 006

GUJARAT

EMAIL : - modyps@gmail.com

Dated 10th July 2006

To,

The Public Information Officer

Police Commissioner's Office

Shahibaug, Ahmedabad

Sir,

Subject:- Information under Right to Information Act under Section 6(1).

  1. Pursuant to email dated 15-3-2006 and 19-4-2006 to the Honorable Chief Minister of Gujarat , the office of the Honorable Chief Minister of Gujarat had issued instructions to the Home Department and the same was conveyed to the Police Commissioner Office at Shahibaug. The Office of the Police Commissioner vide reference no G/725/CP Application -2031/2006 dated 10-5-2006 had instructed the Deputy Commissioner of Police - Zone 1 to conduct necessary inquiry .

  1. On 11th May 2006 , I received call from Shri A K Jadeja , Deputy of Commissioner of Police from Navrangpura Police Station and accordingly , I met him and submitted a brief petition in Gujarati language on 18-5-2006 along with relevant annexures.

  1. On 5th June 2006 , I received phone from Mr. Chudasma , at Vejalpur Police station and was called by him so as to record my statement by him through his assistant Mr, Babulal and accordingly the statement was recorded at about 7 PM in the evening. The said investigation was to be conducted in view of the instructions of the office of the Deputy Commissioner of Police Mr. A K Jadeja vide instructions dated 3-6-2006 under reference number 725/application /Zone 1/ A 165/2006.

  1. Thereafter, I had addressed letter to Mr. A K Jadeja on 13th June 2006 while marking a copy to the Office of Police Commissioner by email giving pertinent information on indifference of Vejalpur Police station.

  1. I had also sent further emails ( 15/6/06, 30/6/06, 1/7/06 ) to the Office of Police Commissioner so as to draw the attention of the negligence of the Office of Deputy Commissioner of Police , Mr. Jadeja.

  1. With this background, kindly furnish the following details forthwith under Right to Information Act:-

    1. What were the steps taken by the Office of the Police Commissioner pursuant to the telegram on 19-7-2000 to stop land mafia Nishit Pethalji Chavada from encroaching bunglow referred in my telegram who has grabbed the possession of the bunglow inspite of status quo orders passed by the Court.

    1. Steps taken by Chudasma of Vejalpur Police station to record the statement of (a) Nishit Pethalji Chavada and his brother Jagdish Pethalji Chavada (b) Chowkidar Mr. Shankar put Nishit Pethalji Chavada at the referred bunglow (C) the office bearers of the Society where the bunglow is situated as to whether Nishit Chavada had brought it to their attention about the court stay orders on 19-7-2000 (d) the recording of statement of the concerned Assessing Officer who had approved Income tax Clearance Certificate in the hot hurry whereby they had approved the sale of such posh bunglow lower than the payment made to the organizers.(e) what steps have been taken by the Police against Nishit Pethalji Chavada who took law in his hands by removing the household kits from the bunglow by taking law in his hands.

    1. Copy of detailed inquiry made on the persons referred in para 6 (ii) .

    1. Copy of detailed report made out by Chudasma looking after Vejalpur Police Station.

    1. Copy of detailed report made by Deputy Commissioner of Police Mr. A K Jadeja .

    1. Copy of steps initiated by the Office of the Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad pursuant to various emails addressed to the Office of Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad.

    1. The steps taken by Deputy Commissioner of Police Mr. Jadeja and Mr. Chudasma (vejalpur police station) to evict Mr. Nishit Pethalji Chavada and his chowkidar.

The above information is needed forthwith as the life of the undersigned and that of my family is in danger ( and can face harassment and torture in future ) on account of various information getting leaked from the Navrangpura Police Station as that can be observed from the recent arrest of Mr. Ghanyshyam Chudasma working with Navrangpura Police Station.

I have addressed affixed Rs 20/- by way of non-judicial stamp towards the requisite fees as per Gujarat Rules of Right to Information Act.

It is vital that the above information be submitted to the undersigned postal address and email address ( email :- modyps@gmail.com ) within 48 hours of receipt of the present petition letter being addressed to the Public Information Officer in light of the safety of the undersigned and his family.

Thanking You.

Yours sincerely,

Pankaj S Mody



Sunday, July 02, 2006

email to police commissioner on 2nd July 2006


why Chudasma heading Vejalpur Police station does not bark against land mafia Nishit pethalji chavada for so long ???

pankaj mody Sun, Jul 2, 2006 at 1:45 PM
To: rdr-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, csguj@gujarat.gov.in, secinb@gujarat.gov.in, narendrabhai d modi , sectocm@gujarat.gov.in, as-lno-home@gujarat.gov.in, presidentofindia@rb.nic.in
Cc: deepak.chaurasia@aajtak.com, rajdeep.sardesai@tv18online.com, barkha@ndtv.com, sardesai.rajdeep@gmail.com, editorial@sandesh.com, gujaratsamachar , Lok Satta Gujarat , MEDIA_Tehelka , Maria , mail@indiatv.com, mail@aajtak.com, uday mahurkar , ahmedabadnewsline@expressindia.com, dhruv chauhan , vinod mehta , MEDIA_IE_Mumbainewsline
TOP PRIORITY AND FOR IMMEDIATE PERSONAL ATTENTION OF POLICE COMMISSIONER - MR KAUSHIK.
from: Pankaj S Mody
mobile 94270-26109
2nd July 2006
The Police Commissoner , Ahmedabad
Shahibaug
Ahmedabad
Respected Sir,
For immediate personal attention of Shri Kaushik , Police Commissioner
This is in continuation to my earlier email to you and is annexed herewith for your ready reference.
Mr. R S CHUDASMA is ASSITANT COMMISSIONER OF POLICE who oversees various police stations and sits at Vejal Pur Police station. His name has become controversial in light of name of Police Inspector Mr. Rathod ( Ellisbridge Police station ) was tainted as per the news paper report.
I have already narrated the conduct of Vejalpur Police station in my earlier emails to you and hence it is necessary to find out the detailed inquires made by him against Nishit Pethalji Chavada - land mafia .
Under no circumstances you can cover up his actions especially when I Have already conveyed earlier that even Deputy Commissioner of Police Mr Jadeja claimed to be powerless in questioning Mr. R S Chudasma. Does all the events do not suggest that they are hand in glove especially on account of adverse reports on Mr Rathod - Police Inspector at Ellisbridge Police station.
Kindly conduct on the spot investigation personally to check the performance and integrity of Mr. R S Chudasma who recorded my statement at Vejalpur police station on 5th June 2006 and till date nothing has been done by Mr Babulal working under him inspite of having reported to Mr. Jadeja - Deputy Commissioner of Police - Mr. Jadeja
Such lethargy and sloth and indifference and careless and negligence cannot be tolerated by you as you are risking the lives of the undersigned as well as my family members . This is nothing but total incompetence and irresponsible mind set of Police . If this is the way the Police force behave irresponsibly than this should be of concern to citizens in Ahmedabad and elsewhere.
I therefore humbly request you to conduct inquiries of Chudasma at Vejalpur Police station forthwith .
For my safety I am circulating the news to media on wide scale for my safety.
By now , the control room of Police Commissioner ought to have taken immediate action to summon Mr. R S Chudasma and his writer Mr. Babulal and found out the steps that has been taken by them in this regard and thereby check their integrity , competence , etc.
I look forward to your prompt action .
Yours sincerely,
Pankaj Mody

Saturday, July 01, 2006

email dated 1st July 2006 to Police commissioner

Gmail pankaj mody

SURFACING OF CHUDASMA’S NAME IN TODAY’S NEWSPAPER - ONE CAN GUESS VERY CLEARLY WHY DCP- ZONE 1 – MR. JADEJA DOES NOT BARK ??

pankaj mody Sat, Jul 1, 2006 at 10:26 AM
To: rdr-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, csguj@gujarat.gov.in, secinb@gujarat.gov.in, narendrabhai d modi , sectocm@gujarat.gov.in, as-lno-home@gujarat.gov.in
Cc: presidentofindia@rb.nic.in, barkha@ndtv.com, sardesai.rajdeep@gmail.com, sucheta dalal , editorial@sandesh.com, gujaratsamachar , Lok Satta Gujarat , MEDIA_Tehelka , MEDIA_IE_Mumbainewsline , MEDIA_AG_Mumbai_Age , vinod mehta , metro@sambhaav.com, divyabhaskar , ahmedabadnewsline@expressindia.com, JANYALASRINIVAS , "dmurali@thehindu.co.in" , "ninan@business-standard.com" , MEDIA_Tehelka_Chandni_Parekh , dhruv chauhan , Jai-hind , skdubeyfoundation@yahoogroups.com, Rupesh Garg , samir , jago-india@yahoogroups.com, Yogesh Pratap Singh , Maria , t.mitul@gmail.com

TOP PRIORITY AND FOR IMMEDIATE PERSONAL ATTENTION OF POLICE COMMISSIONER :- MR. KAUSHIK

FROM :- PANKAJ S MODY

MOBILE : 94270-26109

Dated July 1, 2006

The Police Commissioner

Shahibaug

Ahmedabad

Respected Sir ,

SUBJECT:- SURFACING OF CHUDASMA'S NAME IN TODAY'S NEWSPAPER - ONE CAN GUESS VERY CLEARLY WHY DCP- ZONE 1 – MR. JADEJA DOES NOT BARK AGAINST HIS OWN STAFF ??

  1. Kindly refer to my email yesterday afternoon on 3oth June 2006 annexed herwith and is self explanatory.
  2. Today on July 1, 2006 it has been reported in all Ahmedabad based newspaper about some connection of one Mr. Chudasma working with Deputy Commissioner of Police - Zone 1 – Mr. Jadeja in the case connected with recet killing of Mr. Pankaj Trivedi.
  3. Yesterday on 3oth , 2006 I have sent an email along with enclosure of various emails and the contents are self expalanatory
  4. I am furnishing recent chronological events (marked A) and extract of the contents of recent previous emails sent to you. (marked B)
  5. The sequence of events along with my comments tallies with today's reporting in newspapers would lead one to conclusion that DCP – Zone 1- _ Jadeja has his henchmen working for him and there is nexus why he slows down the inquiry or diverts the issue completely . The instructions given by the Chief Minister of Gujarat are being used to let go the accused go scot free and this is being done by the agents of Deputy Commissioner of Police – Mr. Jadeja himself by his soft and gentle attitude stating that he cannot take away the file from Mr. Chudasma heading Vejalpur Police station.
  6. There is interesting story of Sherlock Holmes in Silver Blaze – The Dog that did not bark and I am repeating the same so that you can draw obvious conclusions of rampant corruption , sloth and indifference prevailing in the lower Police administration .

Gregory ( Scotland Yard detective): "Is there any other point to which you would wish to draw my attention?"

Holmes: "To the curious incident of the dog in the night-time."

Gregory: "The dog did nothing in the night-time."

Holmes: "That was the curious incident."

  1. It is time that you develop your instant rage , wrath and fury against Deputy Commissioner of Police - Mr. Jadeja ( Navrangpura Police Station) and his cronies for their negligence and inaction forthwith by launching immediate inquiries against him so as to create shock waves in the Police administration that they better protect the innocent lives and they do not handle the instructions of Honorable Chief Minister carelessly, slothfully and negligently.

8. As you are Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad , it would be you who would be totally responsible and accountable for any thing that can happen to me or any of my family members by way of harassment , torture or killing by the Police or any outsiders. This is being written with a view that you take ample precautions.

9. The present email is being marked to media and the same is being mass distributed so as to prevent Gujarat going Bihar way.

10. I look forward to your immediate response

Yours most respectfully,

Pankaj Mody

MARKED- A

RECENT CHRONOLOGICAL EVENTS:-

· On 3rd June 2006 DCP –ZONE 1 (MR. JADEJA) gave instructions to Mr. Chudasma (heading Vejalpur Police station ) to conduct inquiry

· On 5th June 2006 , Pankaj Mody received mobile message from Vejalpur Police station that I should go and meet them and give statement which I did.

· On 12th June 2006 I met Mr. Jadeja and on 13th June 2006 , Mr. Jadeja stated that he was not in a position to side track Mr Chudasma ( inspite of his negligence and sloth and carelessness) and this was brought to his attention by letter to him while dispatching email on 13th June 2006 to the office of the Police Commissioner

· On 15th June 2006 wrote email to Chief Minister of Gujarat while giving the phone numbers of Vejalpur Police station so that inquiries can be made by the monitoring cell of Chief Minister of Gujarat

· On 15th June 2006 subsequently sent email to Police Commissioner informing him about the contents of the email sent to Chief Minister

· On 30th June 2006 had sent email to Police Commissioner ( while marking a copy of email to media) of the previous correspondence

· On 1st July 2006 read about one

http://epaper.timesofindia.com/Daily/skins/TOI/navigator.asp?Daily=TOIA&login=psmody&AW=1151724231843

read divyabhaskar about Mr. Chudasma's role ( working with DCP Jadeja) in Pankaj Trivedi's case as per the link as under:-

http://www.divyabhaskar.co.in/newsfromgujarat/newsfromahmedabad/ahmedabadnews_01.asp

read sandesh dated 1 st July 2006 front page article of involvement of one Chudasma in the office Deputy Commissioner of Police office -Mr. Jadeja at Navrangpura

http://www.sandesh.com/

MARKED – B


---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: pankaj mody < modyps@gmail.com>
Date: Jun 15, 2006 7:09 PM
Subject: FOR PROMPT ATTENTION OF POLICE COMMISSIONER OF SHRI KAUSHIK regarding EMAIL DESPATCHED TO HONORABLE CHIEF MINISTER FOR RESTORATION OF POSSESION OF BUNGLOW
To: rdr-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.in

Email:- modyps@gmail.com

15th June 2006,

THE POLICE COMMISSIONER OF AHMEDABAD



---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: pankaj mody < modyps@gmail.com>


Date: Jun 15, 2006 6:37 PM


Subject: DIRECTIONS GIVEN BY YOUR OFFICE PURSUANT TO MY EMAIL DATED APRIL 19 2006 FOR RESTORATION OF AMRASHAGUN BUNGLOW


To: CM Gujarat < cmgujarat@gujaratindia.com >


Cc: secinb@gujarat.gov.in, hasmukha@gujarat.gov.in, csguj@gujarat.gov.in, sectocm@gujarat.gov.in, pa1tocm@gujarat.gov.in




The Honorable Chief Minister of Gujarat

Government of Gujarat

All the good efforts put by the Honorable Chief Minister's office and his immediate subordinates and the present Deputy Commissioner of Police is going down the drain when Mr. Babulal ( writer working with Vejalpur Police station under Mr, Chudasma) is not taking prompt action to investigate the matter especially when the Vejalpur Police station was directed to submit the report within five days ..

It appears that Deputy Commissioner of Police - Mr. Jadeja is a gentle and mild person and hence, he tolerates the indifference and sloth as well as Hoti Hai Chalti Hai attitude prevalent at Vejalpur Police station. This has to change if one has to supervise Megacity. This may be bitter truth but such outward hardness on the part of Mr, Jadeja would generate rich dividends in long run for him as well as Government of Gujarat.

In order that there is ripple effect at lower level there has to be monitoring cell at Gandhinagar itself so that they can question Mr. Chudasma and Mr Babulal (the aforesaid writer) directly at Vejalpur Police station ( their phone number is 26813802 ) and also request the Deputy Commissioner of Police ( their phone number is 26460193 ) to give oral report to Monitoring cell directly under Chief Minister's Secretariat Supervision instead of relying on written reports which are slow , ineffective and can be manipulated so that ground situation do not reflect in the same.

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: pankaj mody < modyps@gmail.com>
Date: Jun 13, 2006 9:51 PM
Subject: copy of letter despatched to Deputy of Commissioner of Police Zone 1 annexed herewith
To: cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.in

13th June 2006

The Police Commissioner

The Deputy Commissioner of Police - Zone 1 , Shri Jadeja has given instructions to Mr. Chudasma - Vejalpur Police station on 3rd June 2006 to investigate the matter with five days. My statement was recorded on 5th June 2006 by the writer Mr. Babulal attached with Vejalpur Police station.

June 13, 2006

The Deputy Commissioner of Police –Mr. Jadeja

Subject:- COMPLAINT NO 725/APPLICATION /ZONE 1/ A 165/2006 NAVRANGPURA DATED 3-6-2006 IN CONNECTION WITH MY EMAIL TO THE HONORABLE CHIEF MINISTER

================================================================

This is in reference to the inquiry on the above subject for which you have been kind enough to give prompt instructions on 3r June 2006 to Shri Chudasma at VejalPur Police station and for that I was called by Shri Chudasma right on 5th June 2006 and I had personally gone to meet him on the same day and had given my statement while explaining the details.

I met you today once again and you stated that you are not in a position to side track Mr. Chudasma as Ramdevnagar Police station falls under jurisdiction of Shri Chudasma ( Vejalpur).

ENCLOSURE COPY OF EMAIL SENT ON 30- 6-2006

--------- Forwarded message ----------
From: pankaj mody < modyps@gmail.com>
Date: Jun 30, 2006 1:28 PM
Subject: SOS Message:- Would Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad draw lessons from Pankaj Trivedi's case so that other crusader PANKAJ is not killed , harassed or tortured on account of negligence of not interrogating land mafia Nishit Pethalji Chavada inspite o
To: rdr-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, csguj@gujarat.gov.in, secinb@gujrat.gov.in, narendrabhai d modi <cm@gujaratindia.com>
Cc: barkha@ndtv.com, sardesai.rajdeep@gmail.com , sucheta dalal < suchetadalal@yahoo.com>, editorial@sandesh.com, MEDIA_Tehelka < editor@tehelka.com >, gujaratsamachar <editor@gujaratsamachar.com>, divyabhaskar < contact@divyabhaskar.co.in>, ahmedabadnewsline@expressindia.com, presidentofindia@rb.nic.in, "dmurali@thehindu.co.in" < dmurali@thehindu.co.in>, djoshi@hindustantimes.com, " ninan@business-standard.com" < ninan@business-standard.com>, " somnath@sansad.nic.in" <somnath@sansad.nic.in>, hcguj@guj.nic.in, dhruv chauhan <dhruv_chauhan@yahoo.com>, Yogesh Pratap Singh < yogeshpratapsingh@gmail.com>, HUM_Rahul_Mangaonkar < mail4rahul@gmail.com>, jago-india@yahoogroups.com, skdubeyfoundation@yahoogroups.com , Jai-hind < Jai-Hind@yahoogroups.com>, kiranbedi@hotmail.com

SOS Message:- Would Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad draw lessons from Pankaj Trivedi's case so that other crusader Pankaj is not killed , harassed or tortured on account of negligence of not interrogating land mafia Nishit Pethalji Chavada inspite of instructions from the Chief Minister ???

From: Pankaj S Mody

Email : modyps@gmail.com

Mobile number :- 94270-26109

29th June 2006,

For the immediate personal attention of Shri Kaushik , Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad.

The Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad

Shahibaug

Ahmedabad

Respected Sir,

This is in continuation of the email dated 15th June 2006 sent earlier to you.

  1. Just like Mr Pankaj Trivedi is a crusader and whistleblower, I am similar crusader and whistleblower and was one of the pioneers which blew whistle against Jatin Jalundhwala of Core Healthcare colluding with Global Trust Bank to create false documentation of creation of charge of Rs 12.5 crores on immoveable property.

  1. At the outset let me give an instance of low caliber of the staff at Navrangpura Police station who have asked the Ellisbridge police station to record my statement through Chadavad on account of my email of thanks sent to the Chief Minister of Gujarat as annexed herewith. The email dated is being placed in form of link as under:-

http://pocom.blogspot.com/2006/05/email-sent-to-chief-minister-of.html

  1. From the newspaper report , the Police Inspector of Ellisbridge Police has been negligent in his duties as reported in local news papers and who was investigating the case involving the killing of Mr. Pankaj Trivedi. He has also failed in his duties even when the directions of Chief Minister of Gujarat were given to Home department and subsequently the same was passed to Paldi Police chawky coming under jurisdiction of Ellisbridge Police station. I am annexing two relevant links for your immediate attention. The Ellisbridge Police station has not taken any appropriate steps to extend protection inspite of copy of letter addressed to them along with the names of the persons

http://corinq.blogspot.com/2005/02/letter-from-additional-principal.html

http://corinq.blogspot.com/2005/07/e-mail-on-21st-july-2005.html

  1. How can we expect to trust when various police officers and expect safety from them when the police officers do not know how to interpret what is written and for them every document or correspondence is greek and latin. How do we expect that they will not take bribes in to day's world of galloping inflation.How can they be relied upon to conduct inquiry which involves police remand when they do not understand language and the basics at all. How is it being ensured that they will not take bribes from rich and famous. What methods are being implemented to verify their literacy by citizens groups so that the innocent people and their families are not harassed.

  1. How can we rely on Police administration where the sensitive issues involving names of land mafia gets leaked to any tom ,dick and harry and the risk of possible damage in form of death, harassment or torture that can be caused to me and family members.

  1. I look forward to your prompt reply and you as a responsible Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad would be solely responsible for negligence in performing duties incase any of my family member as well as the undersigned gets killed , harassed or tortured on account of land mafia grabbing the possession of Amrashagun bunglow by taking law in his hands.

  1. Please do not blame me if any harassment , torture , or death that can happen to me and /or any family member and haunts you for rest of your life on account of negligence and carelessness on your part from now onwards if you do not repair and mend situation that has been caused on account of sloth and in competency of various police administration.

  1. Kindly see that you do not play with the lives of the whistleblowers and crusaders after having experienced the death of whistleblower cum crusader Mr. Pankaj Trivedi on account of negligence on the part of administration working under you. Any damage in any form to another whistleblower / crusader named Pankaj Mody ( that is the undersigned and my family members)would tarnish your name irreparably especially after the present precautionary message.

  1. It is therefore humbly requested that suitable steps to ruthlessly interrogate Nishit Pethalji Chavada and the chowkidar residing in Bunglow 1 of Amrashagun extensively and minutely forthwith on receipt of present email.

  1. It is expected of you to restore my possession rights of the bunglow grabbed by land mafia Nishit Pethalji Chavada in light of instructions from responsible Honorable Chief Minister of Gujarat

  1. For an elderly person each penny spent on writing to the Police administration is painful and hence be kind to have a policy that the same is recovered from the salary from the all concerned officers by fining them sufficiently and recovering it from their salary so that other persons in the city do not have to go through such agony and anguish for bearing expense of typing and dispatching to various persons and such expense can run from Rs 50 to Rs 300. You can imagine that inspite of endless communication the Police department does not move an inch unless police is being paid handsome bakshish. Only thing that is happening is endless internal written reports. Very soon Gujarat is going to have the Honour of super ceding Bihar state if one sits down and notes the change of events happening in this city and timidity on part of Police administration to interrogate powerful and influential figures such as Nishit Pethalji Chavada.

  1. The present email is being communicated to large number of media persons today itself and hence it is expected that suitable action steps begin today itself on a war footing before more damage is to me and my family members.

I humbly request you to furnish detailed steps taken in this regard while ensuring safety measures to protect the lives of the undersigned as well as my family members. I have started feeling the foul play of my opponents already named in my communication in July 2005 and I am able to feel its impact on account of various methods and forces being used to silence me and my family members.

Thanking you.

Yours most respectfully,

Pankaj S Mody



---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: pankaj mody < modyps@gmail.com>
Date: Jun 15, 2006 7:09 PM
Subject: FOR PROMPT ATTENTION OF POLICE COMMISSIONER OF SHRI KAUSHIK regarding EMAIL DESPATCHED TO HONORABLE CHIEF MINISTER FOR RESTORATION OF POSSESION OF BUNGLOW
To: rdr-ahd@gujarat.gov.in, cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.in

From : Pankaj S Mody

2nd Floor , Jnamangal Apt

40 Brahman Mitra Mandal Soc

Paldi , Ahmedabad 380 006

Email:- modyps@gmail.com

15th June 2006,

THE POLICE COMMISSIONER OF AHMEDABAD

SHAHIBAUG

AHMEDABAD

Respected Sir,

I am enclosing copy of email sent to the Honorable Chief Minister of Gujarat for your information and prompt action for effective investigation forthwith ( pending with Vejalpur Police station) so as to restore the possession of Amrashagun Bunglow near New RamdevNagar Police Station near Iskon .

Thanking you.

Yours sincerely,

Pankaj S Mody

Mobile no 94270-26109


---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: pankaj mody < modyps@gmail.com>
Date: Jun 15, 2006 6:37 PM
Subject: DIRECTIONS GIVEN BY YOUR OFFICE PURSUANT TO MY EMAIL DATED APRIL 19 2006 FOR RESTORATION OF AMRASHAGUN BUNGLOW
To: CM Gujarat < cmgujarat@gujaratindia.com>
Cc: secinb@gujarat.gov.in, hasmukha@gujarat.gov.in, csguj@gujarat.gov.in, sectocm@gujarat.gov.in, pa1tocm@gujarat.gov.in

From : Pankaj S Mody

2nd Floor , Janmangal Apt

Near Kutchi Samaj Hall

40 Brahman Mitra Mandal Society,

Paldi

Ahmedabad 380 006

Email :- modyps@gmail.com

Mobile:- 94270-26109

The Honorable Chief Minister of Gujarat

Government of Gujarat

Gandhinagar,

Respected Sir,

SUBJECT:- RESTORATION OF POSSESSION OF BUNGLOW

This is in reference to the directions given to Navrangpura Police station pursuant to my Email dated April 19 , 2006 to your Honor for restoration of possession of Amrashagun Bunglow grabbed by land mafia Mr. Nishit Pethalji Chavada and subsequently the matter was being looked into by Shri Jadeja , Deputy Commissioner of Police – Zone 1 at Navrangpura Police Station by assigning the same to Vejalpur Police Station on 3-6-2006.

All the good efforts put by the Honorable Chief Minister's office and his immediate subordinates and the present Deputy Commissioner of Police is going down the drain when Mr. Babulal ( writer working with Vejalpur Police station under Mr, Chudasma) is not taking prompt action to investigate the matter especially when the Vejalpur Police station was directed to submit the report within five days . A citizen expects prompt action at lowest level of functioning and expects results from them. Elie Wiesel said : Indifference to me , is the epitome of Evil and that is what exactly Mr. Babulal ( the aforesaid writer) 's indifference has caused Investigating matter placed in the hands of Mr. Babulal and others like him would reflect badly of the Police force's competency. This should not be accepted by higher echelon of the Police force and / or the leaders . They should take appropriate steps to ensure effective management of police investigation and at all material time sloth and lethargy on the lower echelon of the police should be minimized by non-toleration of the same from the effective leaders like you.

It appears that Deputy Commissioner of Police - Mr. Jadeja is a gentle and mild person and hence, he tolerates the indifference and sloth as well as Hoti Hai Chalti Hai attitude prevalent at Vejalpur Police station. This has to change if one has to supervise Megacity. This may be bitter truth but such outward hardness on the part of Mr, Jadeja would generate rich dividends in long run for him as well as Government of Gujarat.

In order that there is ripple effect at lower level there has to be monitoring cell at Gandhinagar itself so that they can question Mr. Chudasma and Mr Babulal (the aforesaid writer) directly at Vejalpur Police station ( their phone number is 26813802 ) and also request the Deputy Commissioner of Police ( their phone number is 26460193 ) to give oral report to Monitoring cell directly under Chief Minister's Secretariat Supervision instead of relying on written reports which are slow , ineffective and can be manipulated so that ground situation do not reflect in the same.

The land mafia like Mr. Nishit Chavada can prove to be dangerous for small families like mine when the investigation is slow and carried out indifferently and in a Hoti Hai Chalti Hai manner.

When persons like Mr. Babulal (the aforesaid writer) etc are the real hurdles in Police investigation and their sloth and lethargical attitude causes them to overlook and /or disregard the instructions of the Honorable Chief Minister. Such people would behave horrendously with any ordinary citizen.

Sir , I cannot afford to rely on such Babulal ( the aforesaid wirter) at Vejalpur Police station who do not communicate nor revert back by calling me on the mobile number that is with them already and when Vejalpur Police station does not ask Ramdevnagar police station to investigate the matter and interrogate Mr. Nishit Chavda, his chowkidar , the Society officials where the bunglow is situated and staff who issued notice for shortfall in stamp duty , the concerned Income tax officials who gave their consent overnight, etc. By now Nishit Chavada and his chowkidar would have been grilled and questioned by competent police officers instead of aforesaid Mr. Babulal as Mr. Nishit Chavada had breached court's injunction (for status quo then obtained by me) and had taken the law in his hands by taking illegal possession of the bunglow Amrashagun and by throwing out my family household goods therein .I had already given on 18 th May 2006 copy of my telelgram addressed to the Police Commissioner on 19-7-2000 ( to prevent Nishit Chavada's trespass ) but Mr. Nishit Chavada proceeded the trespass , breached the court's injunction , threw out my household goods and took illegal possession of the said bunglow.

If such simple issues cannot be swiftly tackled by the Police administration , then people like Nishit Chavada can easily break the law and get away with it in such a situation how can you expect such police administration to protect the GARIMA and GAURAV OF FIVE CRORES OF CITIZENS IN GUJARAT.

I therefore humbly request you that your office talks directly with the Vejalpur Police station and Navarangpura Police Station to restore the possession of the said bunglow to me so that I can reunite my family and save the family from disaster.

Thanking you.

Yours most respectfully,

Pankaj S Mody.

Enclosed herewith email addressed to The Police Commissioner of Ahmedabad along with the letter addressed to Deputy Commissioner of Police - Zone 1 as annexed herewith under:-

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: pankaj mody < modyps@gmail.com>
Date: Jun 13, 2006 9:51 PM
Subject: copy of letter despatched to Deputy of Commissioner of Police Zone 1 annexed herewith
To: cor-city-ahd@gujarat.gov.in

From Pankaj S Mody
2nd Floor Janmangal Apt
40 Brahman Mitra Mandal Society
Ahmedabad 380006
13th June 2006
The Police Commissioner
Shahibaug
Ahmedabad
Respected Sir,
I am annexing enclosure of copy of letter addressed to Deputy Commissoner of Police Shri Jadeja dated 13th June 2006. The contents of the enclosure letter are self explanatory.
The Deputy Commissioner of Police - Zone 1 , Shri Jadeja has given instructions to Mr. Chudasma - Vejalpur Police station on 3rd June 2006 to investigate the matter with five days. My statement was recorded on 5th June 2006 by the writer Mr. Babulal attached with Vejalpur Police station.
Mr. Babulal (writer ) affiliated with Vejalpur Police station has been negligent and incompetent to look into the matter promptly and has been negligent and indifferent and lacks the competency to investigate the matter promptly.
I would appreciate very much if you would kindly look into the matter and take all necessary action in light of contents of my letter as annexed herewith.
Thanking you,
Yours sincerely,
Pankaj S Mody
Enclosure :-

From Pankaj S Mody

2nd Floor , Janmanagal Apt

40 Brahman Mitra Mandal Soc

Paldi , Ahmedabad 380 006

June 13, 2006

The Deputy Commissioner of Police

Navrangpura Police station

Ahmedabad

Dear Shri Jadejasaheb ,

Subject:- COMPLAINT NO 725/APPLICATION /ZONE 1/ A 165/2006 NAVRANGPURA DATED 3-6-2006 IN CONNECTION WITH MY EMAIL TO THE HONORABLE CHIEF MINISTER

================================================================

This is in reference to the inquiry on the above subject for which you have been kind enough to give prompt instructions on 3r June 2006 to Shri Chudasma at VejalPur Police station and for that I was called by Shri Chudasma right on 5th June 2006 and I had personally gone to meet him on the same day and had given my statement while explaining the details.

When I had met you in person yesterday and had explained to you of the evasive and vague replies of Mr. Babulalal ( writer) at Vejalpur station which raises doubt as to whether he is correct in his reply( "that there was no chawkidar present in the said bunglow and no one was staying in the adjoining bunglow"} and when at all material time there is chowkidar in the bunglow and in the adjoining bunglow the owner thereof is staying thereat with his family . He ( Mr. Babulal -the writer) could not tell me on what date he had sent any personnel for such investigation and who was sent.

I had also drawn your kind attention that on account of the said bunglow being located new Ramdev Nagar Police station , it would be more convenient to conduct necessary inquiry from this Ramdev Nagar Police station itself .

I met you today once again and you stated that you are not in a position to side track Mr. Chudasma as Ramdevnagar Police station falls under jurisdiction of Shri Chudasma ( Vejalpur).

In this regard I would like to state that I cannot afford going to and fro to Vejalpur police station and deal with ineffective person like Babulal ( the writer) who does not understand the seriousness of need for investigation at lightining speed especially when one is dealing with land mafia who can pose great threat to my life as well as others. Further I am not aware whether Mr. Babulal ( the writer) is competent to deal effectively with the situation when he has been evasive and indifferent to my inquiry, yesterday.

Under such circumstances , I humbly request you that the further investigation in this matter be carried out at Navrangpura under your competent supervision and in my presence for sake of clarity and transparency and for my safety.

I therefore urge you to find a way out for the sake of efficacy , urgency and importance of security measures and on the grounds of compassion as I am homeless and reunite my broken family.

I had gone yesterday evening with Mr. Bhatti ( a police personnel directed by Police Inspector from new Ramdev Nagar Police station) to the referred bunglow and who had collected the name given of chawkidar ( from chawkidars wife) as one Mr. Shankar and she stated that they were looking after the same bunglow on the instructions of Munna.And she had given mobile number of Mr. Tushar , a friend of aforesaid Mr. Munna .

The above information could have been obtained by any competent personnel from the vejalpur police station by directing Ramdevnagar Police chawky in five minutes with expense of Rs 10 rickshaw and instead I had to go all the way to Vejalpur Police station and then to Ramdevnaga Police station incurring around Rs 300 rickshaw expense and about five hours of my time at a time when I am unable to afford such heavy expenses.

Kindly be informed that the aforesaid Munna is pet name of Mr. Nishit Chavada who has grabbed the possession of the said bunglow.

Your urgent attention would be greatly appreciated.

Thanking You

Yours sincerely,

Pankaj S Mody